GIS Modernisation Research and PoC
Background
Current State of the Module
Separate GIS setup outside of the main ERP web application
Client Amazon Workspaces (VDIs) setup specifically to cater to GIS
Manual python commands (or custom batch files) need to be run by the client in their VDIs to run WES supported GIS operations
GIS currently uses ArcMap Desktop 10.8 which is already in Mature Support phase (with no new updates/releases) and would retire on March 1, 2026
Identified Challenges
ArcMap Desktop software: Obsolete and will soon retire. It has limited capabilities, very generic error messages making it difficult to debug, many geodatabase operations are not supported etc
Lot of manual intervention required to intitate GIS automapper and linking polygon tools.
Objectives
Move away from ArcMap Desktop to a suitable ESRI Desktop suite / product offering
Reduce the manual intervention of logging into VDI to trigger Automapper and Linking Polygons tools
Integrate GIS and the Main ERP Web App
Get rid of the VDIs completely if possible
Improve performance of the current GIS operations
Analysis
ArcMap Desktop (vs) ArcGIS Pro (vs) ArcGIS Online (vs) ArcGIS Enterprise
Criteria | ArcMap Desktop | ArcGIS Pro | ArcGIS Enterprise | ArcGIS Online |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Platform Type | Traditional desktop GIS app | Modern desktop GIS app | On-premises or cloud-based server infrastructure for enterprise GIS | Cloud-based GIS platform for web-based services and collaboration |
Use Cases | Legacy desktop GIS operations | Advanced desktop GIS operations with modern workflows | Centralized, enterprise-level GIS data management and service publication | Cloud-based GIS services and collaboration, accessible via web |
Key Features | Extensive geoprocessing tools, traditional interface, MXD files | 64-bit architecture, 2D/3D integration, Python 3 support, APRX files | Comprehensive server components, secure and scalable infrastructure | Web-based interface, hosted services, easy sharing, and collaboration |
Integration | Integrates with various data sources and Esri platforms | Seamless integration with ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise | Integrates with ArcMap, ArcGIS Pro, and other enterprise systems | Integrates with ArcGIS Pro and supports various web and mobile applications |
ArcMap Desktop & ArcGIS Pro: Desktop apps
ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise: Complete platforms and ecosystem which support GIS
Leaning towards ArcGIS Online (with ArcGIS Pro) because it has
seamless integration with ArcGIS Pro
supports cloud-based License management
ArcGIS APIs for Python
